Deutsch  

Physics

Course: Physics
Group of courses: Mathematics, Natural Sciences

Teaching/course objectives:

Students know the theoretical basis, empirical findings and methodological concepts of women's and gender studies in relation to physics. Students can develop and evaluate the significance of the category of gender for physics. In particular, they can apply their knowledge about the approaches and methods of gender justice to their work in physics. In addition, students can argue subject-based and take responsibility in teams.

Teaching content/subject-specific gender studies content:

Women's and gender studies in physics focus on the issue of interactions between gender relations in society and the content and methods of physics.
The (patriarchal) science of physics displays a lack of self-reflection by making its object absolute, losing any physical contact between the subject, the scientist, and his or her object, and by instrumentalising physics as an instrument of domination. The result is the "Oppenheimer effect": Robert Oppenheimer claims that he did not realise he had invented the nuclear bomb, because he said the product had taken on a life of its own. Additionally, physics tends to overvalue the intellectual and assertive aspects of students and teachers, rather than integrating their entire personalities. Physics should not just be a space for intellectual cognition, but also a place of life, experience and action. In this way, the scientist and his or her subject can come into closer contact, until they can make discoveries at first hand.
These are the challenges that women's and gender studies pursue in the history and practice of physics and in empirical research. First, there is the question of women's participation in physics and in the sciences (Women in Science). Second, possible consequences for the choice and presentation of physical subjects, methods and perspectives have to be analysed as well as the fundamental questions of objectivity, value freedom and the validity of scientific knowledge (Gender in Science).

In the field of the history of (natural) sciences:
The natural sciences focus on nature and the cosmos; physics in particular deals with the behaviour of inanimate matter. Physics attempts to reduce the many different phenomena to a limited number of basic laws and natural elements. This knowledge is the result of a complex process of speculation, experimentation and discovery over the centuries. Physics is seen as a man's field, although women have always played a key role in the discipline. In pre-historic times women were the first inventors gatherers and healers and in the modern day women are professors of physics or even Nobel prize-winners. The more important the work of physics has become in society, the more systematically society has de-valued and hindered the discoveries of women physicists, or even ascribed them to men.

  • In antiquity, both women and men carried out scientific practice. We have proof of 17 female Pythagoreans. Paradigmatically, Hypathia of Alexandria has to be mentioned, a female astronomer.
  • In the middle ages, women attempted to combine science and theology. One example is Hildegard of Bingen.
  • In the early modern period, a new view of physics emerged in the 17th century. It became popular to take an interest in physics for women, too, provided this interest remained a superficial pastime. Significant female physicists include Laura Bassi in Italy, Emilie du Chatelet in France ("She was a great man whose only mistake was being a woman" Voltaire). In the process of professionalisation, men increasingly appropriated women's knowledge, denying the existence of female physicists. Particularly, women astronomers pushed their cosmological challenges with patience and endurance, often working along with their brothers (as in the case of Karoline Herschel) or husbands (such as Maria Cunitz).
  • In the modern period, female physicists continued to publish under male pseudonyms in the 19th century, but succeeded in emancipating themselves from this convention in the 20th century. Women's share of public recognition, such as awards and prizes, remains very small. In Germany, in particular, the percentage of female physicists holding professorships and seats on committees is below international average.

In the field of (empirical) research, extensive work has taken place. This is particularly related to:

  • Gender conceptions in physical knowledge
  • Gender-inclusive physics teaching in school
  • Gender-inclusive physics studies
  • Gender-inclusive career orientation.

This work increasingly integrates the interaction (intersectionality) of gender and other social differentiations (such as class/social stratum, ethnicity, origin, race, sexual orientation, age, etc.).

Studies relating to the practice of physics in women's and gender studies are very wide-ranging. They analyse gendered effects of mainstream concepts, developing specific concrete
suggestions for new approaches on the basis of this analysis. The aim is to help break down hierarchical gender relations.
Further practice-related studies focus on changing the practice of physics by means of gender mainstreaming, integrating participation models for overcoming gender bias.
A third area of practice-related work is the professional practice of male and female physicists, highlighting gender differences and women's contributions to the development of physics. This provides indications for designing degree courses (by placing greater emphasis on working areas in which women are particularly relevant in professional practice).
The above list of subjects should not be regarded as a final canon of knowledge in the area, but as an indication of the broad spectrum of women's and gender studies in physics. The field is constantly growing and changing and subject to a lively academic discourse. Current discussions focus particularly on the issue of differences between women (and between men) and the intersectionality of various social differentiations, as well as the significance of processes of social construction of gender, which no longer allow simple answers to the question of gender-inclusive physics. It is therefore more important to integrate social differentiations and hierarchies into the theory and practice of physics.

Forms of integration of gender studies content into the curriculum:

The gender issue is fundamentally relevant to all areas of physics. The above content should therefore ideally be integrated into all teaching courses. Under the current conditions, however, this is unlikely to take place.

If the content of women's and gender studies in physics cannot be integrated into all modules, we recommend offering a "gender module" or gender elements. These gender elements could be as follows:

  1. "Women physicists in the history of physics" dealing with the historical foundations of women's studies in physics.
  2. "Scientific couples in physics" covering the historical basics of gender studies in physics.
  3. "Scientific critique in physics" on feminist critique of natural and technical sciences.
  4. One or several seminars on "Gender-inclusive physics" (e.g. girls and physics, gender-sensitive career orientation in physics, etc.), presenting the empirical findings of women's and gender studies and "gender-inclusive" concepts based on these findings.

Degree stage:

The above content should be integrated into basic courses (Bachelor's phase). The first module is suitable for the second or third semester, with the other modules following on. Master's degrees should extend and intensify the content.

Keywords:

Laura Bassi, Emilie du Chatelet, Hypathia von Alexandria, Hildegard von Bingen, Karoline Herschel, Maria Cunitz, Physics, Geosciences and Astrophysics, Environmental Physics, Engineering Physics, Mikro- und Nanostructures, Advanced Materials, Space Science and Technology, Nuclear Applications, Bioniks, Imaging Physics, Chemistry, Mathematics

Curricula of related subjects
Chemistry
Mathematics

Provided by
Prof. Dr. Monika Bessenrodt-Weberpals
Hochschule für Angewandte Wissenschaften (HAW) Hamburg
Fakulty DMI, Department Media Technology
Monika.Bessenrodt-Weberpals[at]haw-hamburg.de